What is the difference between copper repiping and PEX repiping?

Replacing old pipes in your home can be a big decision, and choosing between copper repiping and PEX repiping can make it even more challenging. Copper repiping has been the gold standard for decades, known for its durability and reliability. However, PEX (cross-linked polyethylene) is gaining popularity for its flexibility and ease of installation. Both materials have their own set of benefits and drawbacks, so understanding the differences can help you make an informed choice. The Pro Plumbing team is here to help you figure out the best fit for your home’s plumbing needs.

Materials

When it comes to repiping a plumbing system, the choice of materials is crucial. Copper and PEX (cross-linked polyethylene) are the two primary materials used for this purpose.

Copper pipes have been the gold standard in plumbing for decades. They are made from natural copper, a metal known for its durability and reliability. Copper pipes are rigid and typically come in lengths of 10 or 20 feet. The fittings and pipes are usually joined by soldering, which involves heating the copper and applying a filler material to seal the joints.

PEX pipes, on the other hand, are a more modern solution. Made from a type of plastic known as cross-linked polyethylene, PEX pipes are flexible and can be bent around corners without the need for fittings. PEX pipes come in long coils, reducing the number of joints needed and thereby minimizing potential leak points. They are connected using crimp or clamp rings and specially designed fittings.

Durability and Lifespan

The durability and lifespan of the materials used in repiping are critical factors to consider.

Copper pipes are renowned for their durability. They are highly resistant to corrosion, although not entirely immune. In areas with highly acidic or alkaline water, copper pipes may corrode over time. However, in most conditions, copper piping can last over 50 years, with some installations lasting much longer. Copper is also capable of withstanding high water pressures and extreme temperatures, making it a robust choice for most plumbing systems.

PEX pipes are also highly durable but in different ways. They are resistant to scale and chlorine, which can degrade other types of pipes over time. PEX is also impervious to corrosion and is less likely to develop pinhole leaks. The typical lifespan of PEX piping ranges from 30 to 50 years, although advancements in manufacturing may extend this period.

Installation

The installation process for copper and PEX repiping varies significantly, affecting both the complexity and the time required for the job.

Copper installation or repiping is a labor-intensive process. It involves measuring and cutting the pipes to size, fitting them together, and soldering the joints. This requires a skilled plumber with experience in working with copper. The rigidity of copper means that more fittings are needed to navigate the plumbing system, which can add to the installation time and cost.

PEX repiping is generally quicker and easier. The flexibility of PEX allows it to be snaked through walls and around obstacles without the need for numerous fittings. The lack of need for open flames during installation also makes it a safer option. For these reasons, PEX is often the preferred choice for repiping projects, particularly in retrofits and complex plumbing layouts.

Cost

Cost is a significant factor in deciding between copper and PEX repiping.

Copper pipes are generally more expensive than PEX. The cost of copper as a raw material is higher, and it can fluctuate based on market demand. Additionally, the labor-intensive installation process for copper adds to the overall cost. Professional plumbers skilled in working with copper may charge higher rates for their services.

PEX pipes offer a more cost-effective solution. The material itself is less expensive than copper, and the ease of installation translates to lower labor costs. PEX requires fewer fittings and less time to install, which can significantly reduce the total project cost. Despite the lower initial cost, PEX still offers durability and reliability, making it a cost-effective choice for many plumbing applications.

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of repiping materials is an important consideration for environmentally conscious homeowners and builders.

Copper is a natural material and is fully recyclable. However, the mining and extraction processes required to produce copper pipes can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. The manufacturing process also consumes a considerable amount of energy. On the plus side, copper pipes have a long lifespan, which means they do not need to be replaced as frequently, potentially reducing their overall environmental footprint.

PEX is made from petroleum-based products, which raises concerns about its environmental impact. The production of PEX consumes fossil fuels and produces greenhouse gases. Additionally, PEX is not typically recyclable, which means it may end up in landfills at the end of its useful life. However, the manufacturing process for PEX is less energy-intensive than that for copper, and its long lifespan means it will not need to be replaced as often. Some manufacturers are also working on developing more sustainable production methods for PEX.

Health and Safety

Health and safety are critical factors in choosing plumbing materials, as they directly impact the quality and safety of drinking water.

Copper is generally considered safe for drinking water. It does not release harmful substances into the water, and any copper ions that do leach into the water are typically within safe limits set by health authorities. However, in areas with highly acidic water, copper pipes may corrode, leading to higher levels of copper in the water, which can be harmful if consumed in large quantities over time.

PEX is also considered safe for drinking water, and it has been approved for use in potable water systems by various health and safety agencies. There have been concerns about the potential for chemical leaching, particularly in the early days of PEX usage. This is typically not an issue in indoor installations but should be considered for any outdoor applications.

Resistance to Freezing

The ability of plumbing materials to resist damage from freezing temperatures is a critical consideration, particularly in colder climates.

Copper pipes are rigid and do not handle freezing temperatures well. When the water inside a copper pipe freezes, it expands, which can cause the pipe to burst. This is because copper has little flexibility and cannot accommodate the expansion of frozen water. To mitigate this risk, copper pipes must be insulated, especially in areas where temperatures drop below freezing regularly.

PEX pipes have a distinct advantage in freezing conditions. PEX is a flexible material that can expand slightly when water inside the pipe freezes. This flexibility allows PEX to absorb the expansion of ice, reducing the likelihood of the pipe bursting. While PEX is not entirely immune to damage from freezing, its resistance is much higher compared to copper, making it a safer choice for climates with harsh winters.

Noise

Noise generated by plumbing systems can be a nuisance in residential and commercial buildings.

Copper pipes can be quite noisy when water flows through them, especially at high pressures. The rigidity of copper means that water hammer—a phenomenon where moving water suddenly stops or changes direction, causing a loud banging noise—can be a common issue. This noise can be disruptive and may require additional measures, such as installing water hammer arrestors, to mitigate.

PEX pipes are significantly quieter. The flexibility of PEX allows it to absorb the shock of moving water, reducing the incidence of water hammer. This can be particularly beneficial in residential settings where noise reduction is a priority.

Maintenance

Maintenance requirements and ease of repair are important considerations for any plumbing system.

Copper pipes require more maintenance over their lifespan. Although copper is durable, it is prone to corrosion and the development of pinhole leaks over time, especially in areas with aggressive water chemistry. Repair to copper pipes often involve cutting out the damaged section and soldering in a new piece, which can be labor-intensive and requires skilled labor. Regular inspections and maintenance are necessary to ensure the longevity of copper piping.

PEX pipes require minimal maintenance. The material is resistant to corrosion, scale, and chlorine, which reduces the likelihood of leaks and other issues. If a problem does arise, repairs are generally easier and quicker than with copper. PEX can be cut and reconnected using simple tools and fittings, without the need for soldering. This ease of maintenance makes PEX a convenient option for homeowners and building managers.

Water Quality

The impact of plumbing materials on water quality is a critical factor, especially for drinking water systems.

Copper pipes are generally safe for drinking water and do not leach harmful substances under normal conditions. However, in areas with highly acidic or alkaline water, copper ions can leach into the water supply, potentially leading to health concerns if the levels are too high. Regular testing and water treatment can help mitigate this risk and ensure safe drinking water.

PEX pipes are also safe for drinking water and are certified for use in potable water systems. Modern PEX materials are designed to minimize chemical leaching, although there were initial concerns about this issue when PEX was first introduced. PEX is resistant to chlorine and other chemicals commonly found in municipal water supplies, which helps maintain water quality. Additionally, PEX’s resistance to scale buildup and bacterial growth further supports its use in potable water systems.

Flexibility and Adaptability

The flexibility and adaptability of plumbing materials can significantly impact the ease of installation and future modifications.

Copper pipes are rigid and require precise measurements and numerous fittings to navigate around obstacles. This rigidity can make copper less adaptable to changes in the plumbing layout or retrofits. Any modifications or expansions to the system require cutting and soldering new sections, which can be time-consuming and labor-intensive.

PEX pipes offer excellent flexibility and adaptability. The flexible nature of PEX allows it to be bent around corners and snaked through walls and ceilings with ease. This reduces the need for fittings and makes PEX ideal for complex plumbing layouts and retrofits. The adaptability of PEX also means that future modifications or expansions to the plumbing system can be made with minimal disruption and effort.

Code Compliance

Compliance with building codes and standards is essential for any plumbing installation.

Copper repiping have a long history of use and are widely accepted by building codes and standards worldwide. The extensive track record of copper in plumbing applications means that it is a well-understood and trusted material for meeting code requirements.

PEX pipes are also accepted by building codes, although this acceptance has grown more recently as the material has proven its reliability and safety. PEX must meet specific standards and certifications to be used in potable water systems, and its use is regulated by codes that govern plumbing installations. It is important for installers to ensure that PEX installations comply with local codes and standards.

Aesthetics

While aesthetics may not be the primary consideration for most plumbing systems, it can be a factor in certain applications.

Copper pipes have a distinctive metallic appearance that some homeowners and designers find appealing, particularly in exposed installations. The clean, shiny look of new copper can add a touch of industrial or vintage charm to a space. However, over time, copper develops a patina, which some may find less desirable.

PEX pipes are typically not chosen for their aesthetic qualities. They are usually installed behind walls and ceilings where they are not visible. PEX comes in different colors, such as red, blue, and white, which can be useful for identifying hot and cold water lines but is generally not a factor in design decisions. In applications where the appearance of the plumbing is a consideration, copper may be preferred for its visual appeal.

Conclusion

Choosing between copper and PEX repiping depends on your specific needs and circumstances. Copper is highly durable, resistant to bacteria, and has a long lifespan, making it a great choice for those seeking longevity and reliability. On the other hand, PEX offers flexibility, easier installation, and resistance to freezing, which can be advantageous in certain climates or for retrofitting projects. Both materials can effectively update your plumbing system, so consider factors like budget, installation complexity, and your home’s environment. Consulting with a professional plumber can also provide valuable insights tailored to your situation, ensuring you make the best decision for your home.

Scroll to Top